[Photo Credit: By Senator Lisa Murkowski - YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMTjsy9hi1I&t=5s – View/save archived versions on archive.org, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/191126160]

DOJ Drops Alaska Senate Lawsuit After Peltola Win, but Criminal Probe Into Namesake Candidate Rolls On

The Justice Department on Thursday moved to end its legal challenge to Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska’s Senate race. It told a federal appeals court the case is moot because Peltola won an outright majority of first-choice votes over Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.

Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward filed the motion with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. It asks the court to declare the case moot, throw out a lower court ruling that dismissed the lawsuit and send the case back for dismissal. Woodward wrote that the United States “reluctantly acknowledges” there is no longer any way to tell how voters meant the ballots they cast for the other Sullivan in the race.

The filing came two days after the Associated Press called the race for Peltola. Her win gave Democrats their ninth Senate pickup of the cycle.

The dispute centers on Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg who appeared on the ballot with no party preference and the same name as the two-term Republican incumbent. The New York Times reported text messages and other documents that appeared to show Peltola’s campaign helped recruit the namesake candidate.

Peltola has denied any involvement and said she was “not interested in tricking voters.” Sullivan Jr. has long said he entered the race on his own, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled that his candidacy was legal.

The Justice Department sued Alaska election officials on Oct. 22 at President Trump’s direction. The lawsuit was built around one scenario. If Sen. Sullivan lost by fewer votes than his namesake received, the department wanted certification put on hold while investigators examined those ballots.

“I’m the one that said ‘do it,’” Trump said of the lawsuit. He has also called for Peltola to be prosecuted.

U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on Nov. 1. She found that the federal government lacked standing and that setting aside ballots would violate the secret ballot. The department appealed the same day. Alaska’s Department of Law, under the state’s Republican administration, had called the suit meritless and backed its dismissal.

Peltola’s outright majority ended the close-finish scenario the lawsuit depended on.

The fight is not over, however. Federal prosecutors are still investigating whether Democrats recruited Sullivan Jr. to pull votes from the incumbent. On Election Day, prosecutors sent target letters to several people, including Democratic election lawyer Marc Elias, whose firm represents Peltola’s campaign. Elias said the department was targeting him and his firm. No one has been charged, and the department has not said which laws may have been broken.

Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy, a Republican, has ordered a separate state investigation into Peltola’s campaign. Before the election, the Justice Department’s top prosecutor in Alaska called the Times’ reporting “troubling.”

House Oversight Committee Chairman James Comer said Peltola’s majority “will probably create issues” for the department but that he believes “there is still a case.”

Sen. Sullivan has not conceded. His campaign said it will let the process play out until every legal vote is counted and certified.

Peltola said she is ready to move on. “I’m eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans,” she said.

The state is aiming to certify the results on Nov. 25. If they hold, Peltola will be sworn in on Jan. 3, when the new Congress convenes.

[READ MORE: Senate Panel Pulls the Plug on Trump’s Pick to Lead the National Science Foundation]

expure_slide