[Photo Credit: Team New Orleans, US Army Corps of Engineers]

Senate Panel Pulls the Plug on Trump’s Pick to Lead the National Science Foundation

Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., abruptly canceled a committee vote Wednesday on President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the National Science Foundation (NSF). The move is a setback for the White House’s effort to put former Health and Human Services official Jim O’Neill in charge of the agency.

Cassidy chairs the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee. At the start of the panel’s Nov. 18 business meeting, he announced that O’Neill would not get a vote and said the nominee lacked the support to advance.

Cassidy pointed to O’Neill’s record at HHS and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. He said O’Neill’s role in the firing of former CDC Director Susan Monarez “raised further concerns about the independent judgment he would bring to NSF.”

Cassidy also said O’Neill did not do enough to stand up for science at the CDC and failed to push back hard enough on controversial directives from HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

O’Neill is a tech investor and a longtime associate of billionaire Peter Thiel. The Senate confirmed him as HHS deputy secretary in June 2025. He took over the CDC on a temporary basis after Monarez was forced out in August 2025, following her clashes with Kennedy over vaccine recommendations.

Kennedy later removed O’Neill as part of a broader shake-up at HHS, and White House officials said Trump would tap him to run NSF. The nomination went to the Senate in March. The agency’s last Senate-confirmed director, Sethuraman Panchanathan, resigned in April 2025.

O’Neill’s background in hedge funds and venture capital drew fire from the start. If confirmed, he would have been the first NSF director who was not a scientist. NSF is an independent federal agency that hands out billions of dollars in research funding to universities and institutions across the country.

The nomination sat stalled for months before Cassidy scheduled a vote, and he scheduled it without holding a public confirmation hearing. That decision sparked a backlash.

On Monday, Democratic Sens. Maria Cantwell of Washington and Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin sent Cassidy a letter demanding a hearing first.

“A nominee preparing to lead this agency should explain how he intends to implement the important authorities Congress has vested in the NSF before the Senate votes, not after,” the senators wrote.

Rep. Zoe Lofgren, D-Calif., made a similar request back in June. She questioned O’Neill’s qualifications and his involvement in a controversial vaccine research grant. More than 100 scientific organizations also signed a letter urging the committee to hold a hearing. The Senate has not held a confirmation hearing for an NSF director since 1991.

The left-leaning Union of Concerned Scientists also lobbied against O’Neill. Its president, Gretchen Goldman, called him an “unacceptable and unfit nominee” days before the scheduled vote.

The committee did not set a new date for a vote, and it is unclear whether the administration will keep backing O’Neill or name someone else.

Time is running short. If O’Neill is not confirmed by the end of the year, the White House will have to send his nomination again to the new Senate that convenes in January. Cassidy lost his Republican primary in May and is serving out the final weeks of his term.

For now, NSF remains without a Senate-confirmed leader, and research administrators are watching for any effect on grant cycles and agency policy.

[READ MORE: Vance Bails on New York Times Summit Minutes Before Showtime to Handle Nationwide Tech Outages]

expure_slide