CNN commentator Van Jones reportedly delivered a pointed critique of New York City’s mayor-elect, Zohran Mamdani, on Tuesday night, arguing that the progressive firebrand revealed “a little bit of a character switch” in his victory speech and “missed an opportunity” to unite rather than divide.
Mamdani, who defeated independent candidate Andrew Cuomo by eight points in what he called a “mandate for a new kind of politics,” presented himself during the campaign as a reform-minded progressive aiming to bring change to City Hall. But Jones suggested the tone and substance of his speech signaled something different — a sharper, more strident figure than the one many voters thought they were supporting.
“I think he missed an opportunity,” Jones said moments after Mamdani’s remarks. “The Mamdani that we saw on the campaign trail — who was a lot more calm, who was a lot warmer, who was a lot more embracing — was not present in that speech. And I think that Mamdani is the one you need to hear from tonight.”
Jones went on to question whether Mamdani’s rhetoric would alienate voters outside his left-wing base. “There are a lot of people trying to figure out, ‘Can I get on this train with him or not? Is he going to include me? Is he going to be more of a class warrior even in office?’” Jones said.
The CNN analyst, who has often expressed sympathy for progressive causes, seemed taken aback by the mayor-elect’s tone, describing it as aggressive and off-putting. “I think his tone was sharp,” Jones said. “I think he was using the microphone in a way that he was almost yelling. And that’s not the Mamdani that we’ve seen on TikTok and the great interviews and stuff like that. So I felt like it was a little bit of a character switch here, where the warm, open, embracing guy that’s close to working people was not on stage tonight and there was some other voice on stage.”
Jones’s comments reflected a growing unease, even among progressives, about the combative tone Mamdani struck on election night. His victory speech emphasized class conflict and populist defiance — a message that played well with the activist left but risked alienating moderates and business leaders whose cooperation he will need to govern effectively.
“That said, he’s very young,” Jones added. “And he just pulled off something very, very difficult. And I wouldn’t write him off, but I think he missed an opportunity to open himself up tonight. And I think that that will probably cost him going forward.”
Mamdani’s victory, hailed by progressives as a triumph for democratic socialism, comes amid growing skepticism among New Yorkers about crime, housing affordability, and the city’s economic direction. While his campaign appealed to frustration with the political establishment, Jones’s critique hinted at a deeper challenge: whether Mamdani’s movement-style politics can translate into effective governance.
For now, the new mayor’s tone appears to have divided even his own allies. As Jones’s reaction made clear, Mamdani may have won the election — but his next test will be whether he can win over a city that is still waiting to see which version of him will show up at City Hall.
[READ MORE: Emails Reveal Comey Encouraged Media Leaks Through Confidant, DOJ Filing Shows]
