Private sector hiring showed modest resilience in March, reportedly coming in slightly better than expected, but the details behind the numbers suggest an uneven recovery that continues to rely heavily on a few key industries.
According to payroll processor ADP, private employers added 62,000 jobs in March. That figure topped the Dow Jones estimate of 39,000 and came just shy of February’s revised total, slipping by only 4,000 jobs. While the headline number may appear encouraging, a closer look reveals that much of the growth remains concentrated in limited sectors, raising concerns about the broader strength of the labor market.
As in February, job creation was largely driven by two industries: education and health services, along with construction. Education and health services added 58,000 jobs, matching the previous month’s gains, while construction contributed another 30,000 positions.
Notably, February’s health care numbers had been dampened by a strike at Kaiser Permanente that affected more than 30,000 workers in Hawaii and California, a disruption that has since been resolved.
Nela Richardson, ADP’s chief economist, emphasized that the story of the labor market right now is centered on health care. She noted that while job growth has been steady for two consecutive months, it is far from broad-based. Instead, one sector is doing most of the heavy lifting, reshaping the employment landscape in the process.
Outside of those leading areas, gains were more modest. Information services added 16,000 jobs, natural resources and mining contributed 11,000, and leisure and hospitality saw a smaller increase of 7,000. However, these gains were offset by notable losses in other parts of the economy. Trade, transportation, and utilities shed 58,000 jobs, while manufacturing declined by 11,000 — a sign that some traditionally stable sectors are facing continued pressure.
In a rare moment of balance, job creation was nearly evenly split between goods-producing industries and service providers, with 30,000 jobs added in goods and 32,000 in services. Still, that balance may do little to ease concerns about the overall pace of hiring, particularly as certain industries struggle to maintain momentum.
Small businesses once again led the way in hiring, adding 85,000 jobs. Meanwhile, medium-sized firms cut 20,000 positions, and large companies reduced their workforce by 4,000. This marks the second straight month that smaller employers have taken the lead, a shift that Richardson suggested could reflect a mix of catch-up hiring, inflation pressures, and workers taking on additional jobs to keep pace with rising costs.
Wage growth offered a mixed picture. Employees who stayed in their current positions saw pay increase by 4.5%, while those who changed jobs experienced a larger gain of 6.6%, a slight uptick from the previous month. While wage growth remains steady, it may also point to workers seeking better opportunities in response to ongoing economic pressures.
The ADP report arrives just ahead of the government’s official employment data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Economists expect that report to show an increase of 59,000 jobs following February’s reported loss of 92,000, with the unemployment rate projected to remain unchanged at 4.4%.
Taken together, the latest data paints a picture of an economy that continues to add jobs, but in a way that is uneven and heavily dependent on a narrow set of industries — a dynamic that could prove challenging if those sectors begin to slow.
[READ MORE: Upstart “America First” Democrat Takes Aim at Party Over Gerrymandering, Gun Policy, and Foreign Priorities]
