Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy is threatening legal action against The New York Times. The paper’s crime: quoting something he said in public.
Portnoy, a University of Michigan graduate and one of the loudest Wolverines fans in the country, posted his threat on X on Friday. He wrote that he had not given the Times permission to use an old quote of his and told the paper to delete it or hear from his lawyers.
The quote at issue is three words long: “Kyle Whittingham! Yes!”
Portnoy shouted it in a video he posted publicly in December 2025, shortly after Michigan hired Whittingham as its new head football coach. At the time, Portnoy treated the hire as a triumph, captioning his video with a declaration that the kings of college football were back on top.
The remark resurfaced Friday in a lengthy report by The Athletic, the Times-owned sports outlet. Reporters Austin Meek and Bruce Feldman examined what has gone wrong in Ann Arbor during Whittingham’s first season. They included Portnoy’s reaction near the top of the piece to show how widely the hire was praised by big names in college football when it was announced.
Almost a year later, the mood is very different. Michigan is 5-5 through Whittingham’s first 10 games. The school fired offensive coordinator Jason Beck after nine games, and the offense has struggled badly.
The Athletic’s report also described growing frustration among players, parents and former staffers. Some of those concerns center on Whittingham’s effort to bring the coaching philosophy he built over many years at Utah to a Michigan program with deep traditions of its own.
Portnoy’s legal threat drew a quick fact-check from X users. A Community Note attached to his post pointed out that the quote came from his own publicly available video. It added that news organizations do not need permission to quote public statements made by public figures.
That is long-standing practice in American journalism. Quoting a public figure’s public remarks, especially in reporting on a topic of public interest like a major college football program, is routine.
This is not Portnoy’s first clash with the Times. In 2022 he publicly blasted the paper over a story about his sports-betting ties, accusing it of writing a “hit piece” and disputing its claim that he did not respond to the reporter’s questions. The Times stood by its reporting at the time.
Friday’s dispute, though, is lighter in tone and centered on a football team whose season has gone sideways. Portnoy has spent the past few weeks voicing frustration with Michigan’s results. His enthusiastic endorsement from last December is now being held up as a reminder of how high expectations were.
Whether or not the Times removes the line, Portnoy’s original video and his recent comments on the team remain public. The Times had not publicly responded to his threat.
For Michigan fans, the bigger question is whether Whittingham can turn things around. That will matter far more than any quote that ended up in print.
[READ MORE: DOJ Drops Alaska Senate Lawsuit After Peltola Win, but Criminal Probe Into Namesake Candidate Rolls On]



